The One-Line Answer
Made In wins on high-heat searing and coating-free durability, Caraway wins on effortless release for eggs and fish with a genuine PTFE-free claim, and HexClad's hybrid sits between the two at the highest price -- none of the three is a strictly better version of the others.
These three brands get compared constantly because they solve the same distribution problem -- sell nice-looking cookware straight to a customer's door instead of through a department store -- with three genuinely different constructions underneath the marketing. This is the head-to-head: not which one has the best product photography, but which construction actually fits a given cooking style, and what each one costs you in care and coating lifespan over a few years of real use.
The Three Constructions, in Plain Terms
Made In makes 5-ply clad stainless steel (and a separate carbon steel line) with no nonstick coating on its core cookware -- the same fundamental construction as any good clad stainless pan, sold direct instead of through a retailer. Caraway makes ceramic nonstick: an aluminum body with a mineral-based coating the brand markets as free of PTFE, PFOA, and PFAS. HexClad makes the hybrid described in our full HexClad review: a clad stainless body with a laser-etched surface of raised stainless ridges and PTFE-coated valleys.
By Cooking Style: Searing, Eggs, and Stews
For high-heat searing -- a steak, seared scallops, blackened fish -- Made In's bare stainless surface wins outright, because there's no coating to protect from high heat and no ceiling on how hard you can preheat it. HexClad's ridges get you most of the way there, close enough that most home cooks would be satisfied, but a share of the surface is still coated valley rather than bare metal. Caraway's ceramic coating is the wrong tool for this job; ceramic nonstick is engineered for gentle release, not sustained high heat, and pushing one that hard shortens its already-shorter coating life faster.
For eggs and delicate fish, the order flips. Caraway's ceramic coating releases eggs with essentially no technique required, which is the entire reason ceramic nonstick exists as a category. HexClad's coated valleys do nearly as well. Made In's bare stainless can cook a good egg, but it demands the preheat-and-fat technique any stainless pan requires, and it's the least forgiving of the three for a beginner.
For stews and braises simmering for an hour or more, coating durability and heat retention matter more than release. Made In's stainless or carbon steel has no coating to worry about degrading from prolonged heat and acidic tomato- or wine-based liquid, which nonstick coatings, ceramic or PTFE, are more sensitive to over repeated exposure. This is the category where the coated options' longevity concerns show up fastest.
| Brand | Construction | Best cooking job | Coating lifespan | Full set price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Made In | 5-ply clad stainless / carbon steel, no coating | High-heat searing, braising, stews | No coating to wear out | $500–800 |
| Caraway | Aluminum body, ceramic, PTFE/PFAS-free | Eggs, fish, delicate release | 1–3 years of daily use before release fades | $400–500 |
| HexClad | Clad stainless, laser-etched, PTFE-based hybrid | A mix of both, leaning toward sear | PTFE valleys wear like any nonstick over years | $700–900 list, ~$500 on sale |
Coating Longevity: The Honest Comparison
Ceramic nonstick coatings, including Caraway's, are widely reported to lose meaningful release performance within one to three years of regular use, faster than PTFE-based coatings typically do, even with careful hand-washing and no metal utensils -- a known trade-off of the ceramic chemistry, not a defect specific to one brand. PTFE-based coatings, including HexClad's, generally last longer under the same care, but PTFE isn't PFAS-free the way Caraway markets its ceramic coating as being, and PTFE coatings do still degrade eventually with heavy use, high heat, and dishwasher cycles. Made In's bare stainless and carbon steel simply don't have this problem, because there's no coating to lose in the first place -- the trade is preheat-and-fat technique for anything delicate.
Care: What Actually Shortens Each One's Life
Caraway's ceramic coating is the most care-sensitive of the three: metal utensils, high heat, and the dishwasher all shorten its already limited lifespan meaningfully, so hand-washing with a soft sponge and wood or silicone utensils genuinely matters more here than brand marketing usually admits. HexClad's ridges tolerate metal utensils better because they bear most of the contact, but the coated valleys still benefit from the same gentle care as any nonstick pan. Made In's stainless and carbon steel are the most forgiving -- dishwasher-safe on the stainless line without much real durability concern, and carbon steel just needs the same seasoning routine as cast iron.
Made In 5-Ply Stainless Cookware
See Made In's current stainless and carbon steel lineup and pricing directly, before deciding whether bare-metal durability is worth skipping a built-in coating.
Two Honest Drawbacks for Each Brand
Made In's drawback is upfront cost for a full set without any nonstick pan included -- if eggs and delicate fish are a daily job, you're buying a separate nonstick pan on top of the 5-ply set, since Made In's core line doesn't include one. Caraway's drawback is the shortest functional coating life of the three, and it's genuinely the wrong choice for hard searing, no matter how the marketing photography stages it next to a steak. HexClad's drawback is price: at $700–900 list for the 13-piece set, it costs noticeably more than either single-material alternative, and the coating still wears like any PTFE nonstick eventually.
Who Should Buy Which
Buy Made In if you sear often, don't mind pairing it with a separate cheap nonstick pan for eggs, and want a coating that never needs replacing. Buy Caraway if eggs, fish, and easy weeknight cleanup matter more than searing, you specifically want to avoid PTFE, and you're comfortable replacing the pan every couple of years as the coating wears. Buy HexClad if you want one pan type instead of two, cook a mix of seared protein and delicate food regularly, and the $500–900 price doesn't change your decision -- see our full HexClad hybrid review for the deeper drawbacks.
Match Your Cooking Style to a Brand
Made In
- Best bare-metal sear and heat retention of the three
- Pair with a separate $30–50 nonstick pan for eggs
- No coating to ever wear out or replace
- Least forgiving for beginners on delicate food
Caraway
- Easiest release of the three, minimal technique needed
- Genuinely PTFE-free, if that specifically matters to you
- Expect the coating to fade within 1–3 years of daily use
- Not built for hard, high-heat searing
HexClad
- Handles a mix of searing and delicate food reasonably well
- Costs more than either single-material alternative
- Still a PTFE-based coating, just partly protected by ridges
- See our full HexClad hybrid review for the deeper dive
Reasons to Wait or Go Elsewhere
- A plain clad stainless skillet plus a $30 nonstick pan covers most kitchens for less
- You specifically need dishwasher-proof nonstick performance for years
- A budget under $150 rules out all three DTC lines at full price
- You already own a functioning set in any of the three constructions
Accessories That Work Across All Three
Fine-Mesh Splatter Screen
Works identically well over a stainless, ceramic, or hybrid pan and protects whichever coating you choose from stovetop grease buildup.
Best for: Anyone frying or searing on any of the three.
Wood and Silicone Utensil Set
Safe for Caraway's ceramic coating and HexClad's valleys, and gentle on Made In's polished stainless finish alike.
Best for: Households running more than one of the three brands.
Tri-Ply Stainless Steel Cookware Set
A genuinely capable fully clad set at a fraction of any DTC brand's price, for anyone the $400–900 range above doesn't work for.
Best for: Budget-conscious buyers priced out of all three DTC brands.
Cookware Protector Pads, Set of 12
Keeps any of the three surfaces from scratching against each other in a stacked cabinet, which matters most for Caraway's ceramic and HexClad's coated valleys.
Best for: Stacking multiple finishes in one cabinet.
See Current Pricing Directly
Caraway Ceramic Nonstick Cookware
See Caraway's current ceramic nonstick sets and colorways directly, if effortless release for eggs and fish matters more than searing to you.
HexClad Hybrid Cookware
See HexClad's current 13-piece hybrid set price and any active sale directly, if you want one pan that splits the difference between sear and release.
One Thing All Three Get Right
All three ship direct, cutting out the retail markup that pads a lot of department-store cookware pricing, and all three back their cookware with a real warranty against manufacturing defects. Where they differ isn't quality control -- it's which physical trade-off, coating versus bare metal, price versus convenience, fits your stove and how you actually cook.
There's no single winner here, because the three solve different problems: Made In for high-heat searing and a coating that never wears out, Caraway for effortless egg-and-fish release and a genuine PTFE-free claim, and HexClad for one pan that reasonably splits the difference at the highest price of the three. Pick based on which job -- searing, delicate release, or convenience -- your kitchen actually needs solved most often, not on which brand photographs best.
MORE FROM BORDERLESS KITCHEN
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Caraway or HexClad?
It depends on the job. Caraway releases eggs and fish more easily and is genuinely PTFE-free, but its ceramic coating typically fades within one to three years of daily use. HexClad sears closer to plain stainless and its PTFE-based coating generally lasts longer, but it isn't PTFE-free and costs more.
Is Made In worth it if it doesn't include a nonstick pan?
For searing and braising, yes -- there's no coating to protect or eventually replace. Most buyers pair it with one separate $30–50 nonstick pan for eggs, which still comes out well under the cost of a full HexClad or Caraway set.
How long does Caraway's ceramic coating actually last?
Widely reported at roughly one to three years of regular use before release performance fades noticeably, even with careful hand-washing and wood or silicone utensils. That's shorter than most PTFE-based coatings, which is the trade-off for Caraway's PTFE-free claim.
Can HexClad sear as well as Made In's stainless?
Close, but not quite. HexClad's raised ridges make enough metal contact to build real browning, but Made In's fully bare stainless surface has no coated valleys interrupting contact, so it produces a slightly more even, edge-to-edge sear.
Which of the three is the most beginner-friendly?
Caraway, for release, since ceramic nonstick forgives more technique mistakes than bare stainless does. Made In's stainless line demands the most technique (preheating, using enough fat) to avoid sticking, and HexClad sits in between.
Do any of these three avoid PTFE and last as long as PTFE coatings?
Not yet, honestly. Caraway is the PTFE-free option of the three, but ceramic coatings as a category currently trade away some of PTFE's longevity to get there. Made In sidesteps the question entirely by using no coating at all.